GullFOSS
OpenOffice.org Engineering at Sun
 
 
 
 
More Flickr photos tagged with openoffice

Today's Page Hits: 691

Locations of visitors to this page
« New: OOo-DEV 3.x... | Main | New print UI »
Wednesday, 03 Jun 2009
UI Design Proposals Wrap Up and a Look Forward
Elizabeth Matthis


The Project Renaissance goal is "to know and to understand our users as they are, and to help them accomplish what they want to, by providing efficient access to valuable functionality through a desirable user interface."

After gathering data from several user surveys to get to know our users, the next big step toward a new user interface was our call for UI Design proposals which has now been concluded. The topic was Accessing Functionality in Impress, where we focused on the improvement or even replacement of menus. We chose this OOo application as the starting place and "playground" for the proposal writers, but the UI design concepts should be able to be applied to all OOo applications.

The interest and enthusiasm in the call for proposals is record-breaking. The wiki page with the list of proposals has been accessed nearly 80,000 times!

After five weeks of design work and review, we can also provide other impressive numbers.
All in all, 17 proposals were submitted and reviewed by our brilliant and creative community members. Please note that "creative" refers to information architecture--- graphics design is outside our current focus.
They contain a total of 145 user interface design mockups. (Wow!)
There were 80 comments or questions added by OOo-community reviewers.

From the many designs that were submitted, I've copied just a few of the mockups here in hopes of putting wings on your imagination (English translation of a cute German idiom) and to make this blog more colorful. These are not implementations, they are design ideas so don't get all nervous or excited. Just feel the creative vibes!

Special Note: To quickly view more mockups, see slides 21-34 in the status presentation that was held in May.


.





And don't stop scrolling now, here come more!



...and one more just for the fun of it:




What's Next?

The Renaissance team is determining which ideas (note: mixing and matching will happen here!) appear to implement the design directives* most successfully. Those that do will be used to create a handful of (wire frame) prototypes. Some testing of initial wire frames on unsuspecting "guinea pigs" has already begun. ;-) Later, the concepts the Renaissance team is working on will be the basis for mid-fidelity prototypes that will be validated in tests: We need to confirm that the UI changes will be real improvements and will be well-accepted before we roll them out to our whole user base.

The team will publish further information as they go, so stay tuned! The excitement isn't over yet.

Thanks again to everyone who participated and made the proposal phase extraordinary in the true sense of the word.

* For design directives see slides 18 and 19 in status presentation

tags:

Posted by Elizabeth Matthis on 03 Jun 2009  |  PermaLink |  Bookmark to Delicious To Delicious |  Digg this Digg this  |  Comments[6]

Comments

funny said:

Funny that you did not include any screenshots of the only design proposal that made any sense. The ones you presented have really bad usability.

Posted by funny on June 04, 2009 at 05:49 PM CEST #

e7 said:

I don't need a tabbed interface like MS Office-Ribbons. I want a property box like in many IDEs (like in Delphi, Visual Basic/Visual Studio aso.)

Examples:
http://www.vbdotnetheaven.com/UploadFile/dbeniwal321/WPFMenu12302008004015AM/Images/MenuImg1.jpg
http://www.functionx.com/access/windows/properties2.gif

This would be a much nicer UI element.

Posted by e7 on June 04, 2009 at 05:49 PM CEST #

Liz said:

->Funny: This is a random selection of mockups and stands here without any ratings or judgement. I wanted to show the participation and enthusiasm, not a verdict. BTW, there were other mockups I tried to put in the blog but they just wouldn't show up. (see the two "broken" icons? I can't see them in the blog editor and haven't figured out how to remove them. I'm guessing they are left over from my failed attempts to paste in more mockups---maybe even the one you favor. I wish I knew which one that is!) I'm sorry if I was not successful in communicating in this blog that none of the mockups will be implemented as such. This was not a competition for a winning *design solution*, but rather a call for *design ideas*. Hopefully this comment will clarify that.

Posted by Liz on June 05, 2009 at 05:33 AM CEST #

Liz said:

->e7: Thanks for sharing your idea for how to improve the user experience. I think ideas are always good. It's only that some turn out to be bad solutions. ;-) So, lucky for us we aren't at the solution stage yet and can still play with ideas (like yours).

Posted by Liz on June 05, 2009 at 05:47 AM CEST #

Jonas B. said:

The tabbed interface is a nightmare when it gets complex. A properties based interface has been successful in every IDE out there, and they're as complex as it gets.

Posted by Jonas B. on June 07, 2009 at 03:54 PM CEST #

Jerzy Jalocha N said:

I guess, the broad user-base would hate it, but the best (most efficient/powerful/flexible) UI I've used so far for complex software has been Blender's...

Posted by Jerzy Jalocha N on June 16, 2009 at 12:23 AM CEST #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.
« New: OOo-DEV 3.x... | Main | New print UI » GullFOSS