Blogging Probabilty ChartI have been wondering a bit on why IT industry analysts are not yet blogging. Like many in my field, I occasionally look at what the analysts and pundits are saying about different trends in the industry. <FLASHBACK/> I remember early days in my career when I paid great attention to many different reports from many analyst reports on any topic from CASE tools to RISC vs. CISC to CAD/CAM to RDBMS to almost anything I could get my hands on. Since these reports were exorbitantly priced, the company I used to work for could only afford to buy a select few and that too when the reports were slightly older and probably obsolete. They were certainly entertaining and sometimes enlightening. Am I glad the internet came around when it did. </FLASHBACK>

Anyway, I wanted to check out how my analyst brethren are doing in the blogging world. And here is what I found. Almost no one really blogs in the analyst world. Or if they do, I could not find them. I did a preliminary search to find any blogs out there from any analysts and here is what I found so far:

HAL 9000To make some sense of this, I had a brief session with HAL 9000 and he came up with the chart shown here. According to HAL, the more inclined you are to be an Analyst, the less probable it is that you are going to blog because you already have a full-time job publishing your analysis that makes money for your company. But then, I could have given wrong input to HAL (GIGO, remember), in which case if you know of an analyst blog(s), please provide the link(s) in your comment so HAL can compute.

YouRItBlogging Blog

Comments:

check out RedMonk. and their sharp insight on McKinsey....

Posted by 192.18.42.11 on May 24, 2005 at 05:25 PM PDT #

I am an industry analyst with the CBDI Forum, and I maintain two blogs. An SOA blog at http://www.veryard.com/so/soapbox.htm and a general software industry blog at http://www.veryard.com/industryanalysis/latest.htm. I don't see any contradiction between putting small pieces onto my blog, and publishing detailed analytical pieces through the Forum and elsewhere. cheers, Richard

Posted by Richard Veryard on June 08, 2005 at 03:23 AM PDT #

Because they're afraid they might have to say what they reeeeeeeally think?

Posted by Dennis Howlett on June 22, 2005 at 10:52 AM PDT #

[Trackback] James Governor follows up on a theme raised by Sun uber blogger Deepak Alur&nbsp;but which we aired here some days ago. But not with the same degree of erudition applied by Jimmy. I like the way Jim blow torches Gartner...

Posted by Bazaarz on June 22, 2005 at 11:45 AM PDT #

We maintain a free directory of IT/telecom industry analyst blogs. Currently, we have 98 blogs listed in the directory. Feel free to browse it here.

Posted by Barbara on June 22, 2005 at 06:20 PM PDT #

Analysts can't have blogs for a number of obvious reasons: 1. Their opinions are their job. If their blog doesn't match their 'official' opinion, they would be in trouble. 2. They get paid to express their opinion. Giving it away for free on a blog would not be possible. 3. Blogs are for people who want an outlet for their opinion. Analysts already have one, hence don't need a blog. And if their opinion is in any way different than their official reasearch, again there is a problem. Ultimately, it would clearly not be possible for any serious analysts to mantain a serious blog on the same topic in which he is an analyst. However Gartner etc could offer fee based blogs, which are less formal than their published research.

Posted by Anon on June 23, 2005 at 11:23 AM PDT #

[Trackback] I couldn't resist reviewing these comments: Analysts can't have blogs for a number of obvious reasons: 1. Their opinions are their job. If their blog doesn't match their 'official' opinion, they would be in trouble. Have you ever taken one...

Posted by Bazaarz on June 23, 2005 at 11:50 AM PDT #

Barbara i am not sure you should include blogs that have not been updated for 12 months. that just devalues your directory. Meanwhile Deepak i am interested to know what you think now? you pushed the snowball downhill. it has now picked up some snow - are you go to check out some of these analyst blogs and let us know what you think, and so give the ball some more momentum?

Posted by james governor on June 24, 2005 at 05:45 AM PDT #

Hi James, I am definitely checking out your blog, Richard's blog and other blogs pointed out to me so far. This is a JavaOne crunch time for me so I am a bit slow on blogging right now. I will post an update soon I hope.

Posted by Deepak Alur on June 24, 2005 at 07:05 PM PDT #

I am the most recent addition to Patricia Seybold Group (I have an architecture focus (and background)). You can find my blog here: http://elementallinks.typepad.com/ Patty has been on my case since she hired me to refresh my blog and attach it to our site...the first is done, the second underway.

Posted by brenda michelson on July 21, 2005 at 09:22 AM PDT #

[Trackback] Continuing the conversation in the blogosphere...

Posted by Thought Leadership on October 23, 2005 at 08:03 AM PDT #

Hi, Our analysts blog on all offshoring topics and provide their insights from consulting engagements and share information with the public. -S

Posted by Zinnov Blog on November 17, 2005 at 06:55 PM PST #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.

This blog copyright 2007 by alur