Claire's Alternate Version of Reality
Blogged by Claire Giordano

20050202 Wednesday February 02, 2005

OSDL, Linus and OpenSolaris I spent some time at the OSDL Enterprise Linux Summit yesterday, wearing both my OpenSolaris and open source hats. It was a great opportunity to network and meet with people active in the open source community.  I particularly liked what Linus Torvalds had to say about competition in the Keynote Panel Discussion titled "An Open Conversation with Linux and OSS Notables", a discussion that included Brian Behlendorf, Mitch Kapor, Andrew Morton and Linus Torvalds.  Linus' comments about competition, from my notes:

"Cooperation isn't very motivating. It's a lot more fun to compete. It's good to have competing projects; it keeps everybody honest. If you try to unify too much, people get lazy because they don't see anyone nipping at their heels."

It's healthy that there are competing operating systems and that we push each other to perform and excel.  And of course, the nice side effect of competition is choice for customers, which I believe to be a very good thing.  No business wants the inflexibility that goes along with a single solution, especially when that implies higher costs and less innovation.

I respect what Linus said in Paula Rooney's CRN article titled "Torvalds: Waiting To See Sun's Open Solaris" as well. Linus is an intelligent, articulate and obviously accomplished person.  I respect him.  And for those Solaris community advocates among you, please don't take his "I hope they die" comment personally. I don't believe that he wishes that you, or I, or Andy, or Bryan, or Danese, or any of us die - well, at least not prematurely.  (Linus certainly didn't give me that impression when we spoke yesterday.)  At the end of the day, I suspect Linus would prefer that his creation win the competition and that OpenSolaris be left in the dust.  And that's understandable, and ok.  The thing is, though...  I really don't like dust.

Technorati Tag: OpenSolaris

(2005-02-02 22:31:26.0) Permalink

Comments:

Post a Comment:

Comments are closed for this entry.

links
Archives