The Official Site for Breaking News and the Latest Information from Sun On The Record

Thursday Jun 14, 2007

Three new white papers are now out comparing the performance characteristics and differences between Solaris ZFS and Microsoft, Red Hat and Veritas. 

SOLARIS™ ZFS AND MICROSOFT SERVER 2003 NTFS FILE SYSTEM PERFORMANCE WHITE PAPER Click here for PDF
The Solaris™ 10 06/06 Operating System (OS) introduced a new data management technology — the Solaris ZFS file system. Replacing the traditionally separate file system and volume manager functionality found in most operating environments, Solaris ZFS provides immense capacity and performance coupled with a proven data integrity model and simplified administrative interface. This white paper explores the performance characteristics and differences of Solaris ZFS and the Microsoft Windows Server 2003 NTFS file system through a series of publicly available benchmarks, including BenchW, Postmark, and others.

SOLARIS™ ZFS AND RED HAT ENTERPRISE LINUX EXT3 FILE SYSTEM PERFORMANCE WHITE PAPER Click here for PDF
The Solaris™ 10 06/06 Operating System (OS) introduced a major new data management technology — the Solaris ZFS file system. Replacing the traditionally separate file system and volume manager functionality found in most operating environments, Solaris ZFS provides immense capacity and performance coupled with a proven data integrity model and simplified administrative interface. This white paper explores the performance characteristics and differences of Solaris ZFS and the ext3 file system through a series of benchmarks based on use cases derived from common scenarios, as well as the IOzone File System Benchmark (IOzone benchmark) which tests specific I/O patterns.

SOLARIS™ ZFS AND VERITAS STORAGE FOUNDATION FILE SYSTEM PERFORMANCE WHITE PAPER  Click here for PDF
The Solaris™ 10 06/06 Operating System (OS) introduces a major new data management technology — the Solaris ZFS file system. Replacing the traditionally separate file system and volume manager functionality found in most operating environments, Solaris ZFS provides immense capacity and performance coupled with a proven data integrity model and simplified administrative interface. This white paper explores the performance characteristics and differences of Solaris ZFS and the Veritas File System through a series of tests using the Filebench benchmarking framework which reproduces the I/O patterns of applications, as well as the popular IOzone benchmark which tests specific I/O patterns.

Comments:

These are interesting tests, but there is an anomaly in the ext3 and vxfs mesurements. Since there are 4*2Gb FC links to the array, the maximal bit rate is 8 Gbps = 1 GB/s. It is the same limit as the PCI-X 133 BTW. But there are graphs which show read and write performances above this number, particularly in the zfs vs ext3 paper. At first I thought this was because only zeroes were written and the controller only sent changes, but even if that was the case, we would still be bound to the PCI-X speed (1 GB/s). So I really think that there are some anomalies in some tests.

Posted by willy tarreau on June 15, 2007 at 11:06 PM PDT #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.