Peregrinations

Busted!

Friday May 18, 2007



It is with regret that I read Sam Varghese's critical report of Sun this week, Solaris can never be Linux.  This wasn't just any old nonsense from a blogger posing as a jornalist after all, but the man, the Varg.  Is there a better writer out there?

An elegant wordsmith,
The latest bit of spiel which juxtaposes these words,

but always to the point,
If anything, trying to morph one in order to make it like the other will result in something that is neither fish nor fowl. And we all know what happens when things turn out that way.

with a fabulous command of literary references,
Statistics are often the refuge of scoundrels

and quick to forgive the failings of others,
To put it in his own words:"This paper emphasizes [sic] quantitative measures"

while maintaining his own high standards,
There is no hyberbole, no escessive putdown.

and, as always, in consummate good taste.
Microsoft: shades of Saddam Hussein.




So, when I read that whenever Mr Vaghese hears "the words Sun Microsystems and open source mentioned together [he] can't help but laugh", well, naturally, I'm concerned.  And Mr Vaghese deals out a proper savaging with his irresistable combination of astute observation,

Sun keeps talking about its dedication to the open source ideal and holding on to its code.

quality prose,
Last year, Sun was literally dragged kicking and screaming to the table to release Java under the GPL.

razor-sharp reason,
For years there have been calls to do this but Sun resisted. The act was finally done but who is interested any more?

And industry-insider prescience,
It isn't going to happen. Solaris isn't Linux and will never be anything like it.


No, few survive a mauling from the pen of Mr. Sam Vaghese and laugh it off.


ps. the views expressed here are not necessarily those of my employer


[4] Comments
Like this post? del.icio.us | furl | slashdot | technorati | digg
Comments:

I have never heard of this person.

Also, he criticizes Sun for releasing Solaris under the CDDL, instead of the GPL. Has he similarly criticized Netscape for releasing its browser code under the MPL instead of the GPL? Has he criticized the Apache project for continuing to use the Apache license?

As for Sun and the GPL, he apparently has never heard of OpenOffice.

Posted by Mark on May 18, 2007 at 01:18 PM GMT-01:00 #

Nexenta shows how successful Solaris with GNU tools can be. If Ian's Indiana project is similar, the prospects of success look good. Solaris has a heritage of compatibility with various flavors of tools, and this GNUification just continues this proud history. As a software developer I don't much care which kernel sits under the hood so long as "top", "ps", "ls", "pwd", etc, all work like normal and I can ship my code out of the door working.

Posted by Kevin on May 18, 2007 at 02:20 PM GMT-01:00 #

At 4thscreen.blogspot.com I recently posted by view of the tasks ahead for Sun in taking better advantage of open source. Among those points, I laid out what seems like a simple approach to making Solaris both a contributor and beneficiary of the model that made Ubuntu so successful. It should be do-able, and there are many reasons to look at Solaris, if only it were as easy to make use of as Ubuntu, which is what I currently use.

Posted by Zigurd Mednieks on May 26, 2007 at 03:55 AM GMT-01:00 #

The Belenix team is working toward creating a better user experience on the desktop, though we're not working as hard enough as we could.

I'd given a talk this year (2008) at the Sun Tech Days at Hyderabad on Opensolaris on the desktop.

I believe that people should learn to separate the core OS, the desktop environment, and the integration that a distribution creator does.

Posted by Sriram Narayanan on April 13, 2008 at 03:31 AM GMT-01:00 #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.