Robin Wilton's esoterica

       
 

A day of politics ...


Yesterday was a very interesting one, for me at least, and the common theme seems to have been politics.

The excitement was tempered by the news from Jordan that there had been a series of bomb attacks in Amman, including one at the hotel I stayed in barely three months ago. I hope my friends at STS are all safe and unharmed.

Here in the UK, the Prime Minister suffered his first defeat in a vote in the Commons, over the 90-day detention plans put forward under anti-terror legislation. MPs settled for a compromise figure of 28 days, to the visible anger of Mr Blair.

The government's campaign to get this measure through has been an extraordinary one: the intervention of the Metropolitan Police Commissioner to lobby overtly in favour of the proposal; the evident split between the Home Secretary's desire to find consensus and the Prime Minister's refusal to offer any compromise; the naked appeal to party political 'loyalty' on what is conventionally a cross-party, 'apolitical' topic.

And the episode I find most revealing: at 10:30 on Tuesday night, Labour whips were apparently still confident that they would win the vote. Gordon Brown (the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and Tony Blair's successor-in-waiting) left for Israel where he was to meet both Ariel Sharon and Mahmoud Abbas --- two elected heads of state. By 3:30 on Wednesday morning, the Labour whips knew they were in trouble. Brown was telephoned on arrival in Israel and told to take the next plane back to London to help bolster the vote. This is an unusual step because there's a system of 'pairing' in the Commons, by which two MPs who know they will vote in opposite ways agree that both of them therefore need not actually turn up. It saves having elected representatives attend merely to go through the formality of registering two votes which cancel each other out, when they could be out doing more useful work, such as meeting with two heads of state whose relationship needs all the positive external support it can get.

Mr Brown's recall, therefore, had no practical purpose whatsoever, other than to serve the 'marketing spin' requirements of his increasingly desperate boss. It wasn't enough. The 90-day proposal went down by 322 votes to 291, with several dozen Labour MPs either abstaining or voting against the government.

Meanwhile, in the run-up to all this excitement, I had my first ever visit to the Houses of Parliament, though it was to the 'other side of the lobby': I took part in a briefing session in the House of Lords (!), where a cross-party selection of peers gathered in a committee room for a discussion of the ID Cards Bill. The event was arranged by the London School of Economics, and the Government's argument for the ID Card proposals was put by Andy Burnham, MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Home Office. I was there to offer an industry perspective on the plans. I'll blog about that separately.

It's impossible not to be slightly awed by finding yourself in the country's 'engine of democracy', let alone when you are also expected to address a handful of Lords, Baronesses, party whips and an MP. Right at the beginning of the meeting, though, there was a priceless moment when someone's mobile phone erupted with a loud polyphonic burst... of Jimi Hendrix.

Footnote from the Irony Department: the Anti-Terror bill was being debated on the 9th of November, so my visitor's badge for the House of Commons reads "9/11") So, of course, do many of the banners being displayed today in the anti-extremist marches in Amman.

And to round off the day's political content, BBC4 was showing a re-run of the brilliant 1990 adaptation of Michael Dobbs' dark political satire, "House of Cards". Superbly written, and exquisitely acted (notably by Ian Richardson in the principal role of Sir Francis Urquhart), this was a joy to watch (again) and a great way to wind down after a long day.

 
 
 
 
Comments:

What an interesting day you had Robin!

Here in Ireland many of us were watching this bill with interest. With civil liberties are being taken away hand-over-fist particularly in the US and UK, and we're also seeing it here in Dublin. I'm delighted to see a victory for common sense (yes, I'm aware that this is not the company line).

Loved House of Cards, haven't seen the tv version.

Posted by AMcD on November 10, 2005 at 11:28 AM GMT+00:00 #

Thanks Alastair - yes, all in all a fun time. Well, on the one hand this was a victory, but primarily in the sense of rejecting Blair's approach to the issue, I think. The bottom line is that, at 28 days, the UK will now have a detention limit which is substantially out of line with any comparable democracy.
I was wondering whether anyone still remembered Scott's comment ;^)
Here's how it was put to me yesterday: what effect will it have on a young person seeking medical advice about AIDS, STDs, contraception, pregnancy, abortion, drugs &c., if they now fear that their enquiry will generate an attributable audit trail?
My closing point in the Lords' briefing was that whatever system is put in place must allow assertions to be made about entitlements and attributes in a way which does *not* require the asserter to reveal their identity.
Personally, while I accept that privacy has eroded a great deal, I do not accept that that erosion must necessarily increase over time. There is an opportunity to increase user consent over the use of personal data, and to enable anonymous assertions as outlined above. It's up to us to press for that to happen. [/rant] ;^)

Posted by Robin Wilton on November 10, 2005 at 11:44 AM GMT+00:00 #

Forget that comment? No chance. I admire Scott's no BS, JFDI, approach to a lot of things (one of the reasons I joined Sun), but I strongly disagree with him here.

I believe Danny OB and some of the (ex-?)NTK crew are working on a UK or European EFF. Hopefully that gets off the ground, because I believe if this right wing Labour had their way, the erosion you're talking about would drastically inscrease pace.

But like you say, [/rant] - back to the rugby... ;)

Posted by AMcD on November 10, 2005 at 02:52 PM GMT+00:00 #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.
 
« December 2009
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
   
       
Today

Such views as I express in this blog are based on my own opinions, experience and judgements. They do not necessarily represent the policy or views of my employer. It is not my intention to offend readers in any way. If you find anything on this blog offensive, please contact me in the first instance.
Robin Wilton
www.flickr.com

[RSS Newsfeed]

Valid XHTML or CSS?

[This is a Roller site]
Theme by Rowell Sotto.
What's this?
 
© racingsnake