All | 43 Folders | Accessibility | BoingBoing | Books | Computer Related | Family | Films | General | Hacking | Hobbies | Humor | Java | Links | Omni | OpenSolaris | Puzzles and Games

« Determining Changes... | Main | It's A Small World »
20081024 Friday October 24, 2008

Trying To Fix the Intrusive Firefox

You may remember from a previous post, that if I clicked on a hyperlink in Thunderbird, then Firefox would be intrusive and start up on my current desktop.

The "workaround" was to set "browser.tabs.loadDivertedInBackground" to True via "about:config" in Firefox.

Bug 175904 on Ubuntu's Launchpad has been tracking this problem, and on Monday, an interesting workaround appeared from Jeremy Nickurak

I wrote up a script that I call on opening URL's instead of calling firefox directly. It checks to see if there's a firefox window on the current desktop. If there is one, it'll focus it, and open the URL in a new tab there. If there isn't one, it'll just open a new window right where you are.

Hopefully this'll be useful to somebody.

It requires wmctrl to be installed. (sudo apt-get install wmctrl)

The script is attached to the bug. I thought I'd give it a try.

Well there is no equivalent of sudo apt-get install wmctrl on my OpenSolaris box at the moment, so I downloaded the tarball for wmctrl, unpacked it and tried to build it with:

  $ gzip -dc wmctrl-1.07.tar.gz | tar -xvf -
  $ cd wmctrl-1.07
  $ ./configure --prefix=/usr
  $ make
  $ pfexec make install

Unfortunately it bitched about not having some of the X11 header files, so I had to do:

  $ pfexec pkg install SUNWxwinc

before I was able to successfully build and install it.

Now I needed to get Thunderbird to recognize the new firefox-tab script. I put a copy of it in my own personal bin directory and gave it execute permission:

  $ cd ~/bin
  $ mv ~/Desktop/firefox-tab .
  $ chmod +x firefox-tab

As I previously had set "browser.tabs.loadDivertedInBackground" to True via "about:config" in Firefox, then I had to revert that. I restarted Firefox for good measure.

Then I needed to terminate Thunderbird and add three lines to the prefs.js file in my current Thunderbird profile (~/.thunderbird/hd7h4tp9.default/prefs.js):

  user_pref("network.protocol-handler.app.ftp", "~/bin/firefox-tab");
  user_pref("network.protocol-handler.app.http", "~/bin/firefox-tab");
  user_pref("network.protocol-handler.app.https", "~/bin/firefox-tab");

I then restarted Thunderbird and clicked on a hyperlink. Even though I had Firefox running on a different workspace with several tabs in it, it started up a new Firefox window on my current workspace (where Thunderbird was running). Hmm.

It's definitely running ~/bin/firefox-tab. It's just not doing the right thing. If anybody has any ideas why this isn't working, I'm all ears. For now I've gone back to my previous "workaround".

[]

[]

[]

( Oct 24 2008, 11:25:26 AM PDT ) [Listen] Permalink Comments [4]

Comments:

Hope you created an SFE recipe for it? :)

Posted by Glynn Foster on October 24, 2008 at 01:58 PM PDT #

If it worked it might be worth it. :-)

Posted by Rich burridge on October 24, 2008 at 02:12 PM PDT #

Hey Rich.

I wasn't able to build wmctrl in OpenSolaris -- and not being all that bothered by this bug, I'm not feeling intellectually curious as to why not. ;-) BUT, I just tried reproducing the bug in Intrepid and without any special settings Firefox stays where it belongs. Seems that if you set "only on this workspace", it is respected -- even by Firefox. But not in OpenSolaris.

So then I checked out Metacity's Changelog:

2008-10-23 Thomas Thurman <tthurman@gnome.org>

Support _NET_WM_STATE_STICKY (i.e. allow third-party apps to decide
whether a window is on all workspaces). Bug found by Ka-Hing
Cheung. Closes #557536.

So I think this metacity fix *may* solve your problem -- and the opening report in the bug cited in the ChangeLog *might* answer the question in your entry(??). :-)

Posted by joanie on October 24, 2008 at 04:34 PM PDT #

Thanks for the browser.tabs.loadDivertedInBackground tip! I don't think that used to exist, and I eventually switched to just opening a new window. Now I can go back to new tab, since it doesn't drag all of firefox into the current desktop any more!

Posted by John Levon on October 24, 2008 at 05:06 PM PDT #

Post a Comment:

Comments are closed for this entry.