The Navel of Narcissus
Josh Simons' Coordinates in the Blogosphere

20070411 Wednesday April 11, 2007

Mozy versus Carbonite: Online Backups

I've been shopping for an online backup facility, a service that will back up the files on my laptop to a datacenter somewhere in the network, keeping them safe and encrypted. Both Mozy and Carbonite are working on Mac versions with Mozy's currently in beta. Both currently offer Windows versions.

I haven't yet made a decision. But I did learn something interesting I thought I'd share with others considering these or other, similar services.

As you shop for a backup service, pay attention to their policies limiting either how much data can be uploaded per day or how fast you can upload data to their site. Both Mozy and Carbonite have such throttles in place on their consumer versions with less stringent throttling available for their advanced or pro versions (Carbonite claims they will have an advanced version soon.)

Mozy limits uploads to 1 Mbit/second, which in practice is not the rate-limiting factor for many people since their uplinks run slower than this. Still, if you assume a usable 1 Mbit/second connection, it will take approximately 10 days to upload 100 GBytes of data.

Carbonite is more...interesting. They initially limit transfers to between 2-3 Gbytes per day. After the first 50 GBytes, Carbonite throttles the transfer rate to 500 MBytes per day. According to their estimates, transferring an initial 100 GByte backup would therefore take about 100 days. Ouch.


(2007-04-11 05:00:00.0) Permalink Comments [4]

Trackback URL: http://blogs.sun.com/simons/entry/mozy_versus_carbonite_online_backups
Comments:

The upload speed is a problem -- because I'm in need of some form of "offsite" backup. The problem is I'm wanting to backup almost a terabyte of data with daily, or at least weekly, incremental updates to that 1TB. The online backup services seem to cater more to people needing much smaller types of data backups. My issue is I've mirrored my 1TB of data (photos and music), but I need an offsite solution as well in case of theft, fire, etc...

Posted by Brandon on April 11, 2007 at 09:01 AM EDT #

For online backup news, information and articles, there is an excellent website: http://www.BackupReview.info This site lists more than 400 online backup companies and ranks the top 25 on a monthly basis. Any one can add their company in the directory. Just click on the "Search" button found at the top. Cheers,

Posted by Jennifer on April 12, 2007 at 03:10 PM EDT #

Carbonite took about a week to backup 20-something Gigs of info for me. Slow, but OK. I don't add tons of new info daily, so it's fine.

Posted by Jeff L. on October 02, 2007 at 05:31 PM EDT #

I discovered a Memopal (www.memopal.com) "cutting edge solution for online
backup"

If you try this service you will notice that (contrary to most competitors):
- You can access your files in (true) real time with a web browser
- They really offer 250 GB (some competitors offer a fake unlimited web
space, they say "fair use")
- You can share a file or many files with the 1-click-share functionality
- Some of your files will be uploaded very very fast (turboupload)
- The service and website are in 10 different languages

I've also found two useful guide to online backup on Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_backup

Posted by miky79 on June 24, 2008 at 06:44 AM EDT #

Post a Comment:

Name:
E-Mail:
URL:

Your Comment:

HTML Syntax: NOT allowed

 
archives
links
stats