Superpatterns

Pat Patterson on Identity Management, Federation and Single Malt Scotch
         

accessmanager adoption authentication bloggers burtongroup catalyst community extensions federation google identity libertyalliance lightbulb links opends openid opensource opensso php saml sdn security sso sun webservices
 
Update on WS-Federation, SAML 2.0
[ ]
I posted my previous blog entry as feedback to Patrick Harding's SAML 2.0 article in Network World. Patrick was kind enough to reply this morning, saying that Network World TechUpdate articles focus on a single technology which, in this case, was SAML 2.0 rather than the wider topic of Federated Web SSO. Never mind that writing about the convergence of federation technology into SAML 2.0 without mentioning WS-Fed is like not mentioning the elephant in the room.
Anyway, Patrick gave me his permission to post his excised paragraph:
What about WS-Federation? Anyone using Microsoft's upcoming Active Directory Federation Service will be using WS-Federation, as it is the protocol supported by ADFS. WS-Federation will likely become the second important federation protocol going forward, even though the primary focus of the WS-* initiative is web services. While one could argue the industry would be better off with a single standard, having two is a whole lot better than having seven.
I can't agree more - taking the pragmatic view, we now have a converged standard for federated web single sign-on supported by the entire industry save a single vendor. Perhaps Microsoft could one day join us at OASIS in bringing the benefits of WS-Federation to SAML 2.next?
@ 09:56 AM PST Comments [2]
 
 
 
Comments:

A customers perspective is slightly different than what you suggest in your posting. MS is doing the right things with WS-Federation. After all, if you consider that 99.9% of all Fortune enterprises and their B2B partners have AD installed, they would eliminate not only the need for SAML but for enterprises to buy yet another piece of software that really should be bundled with the OS in order to solve for problems across enterprises. Federated identity conversation is somewhat consumer focused. Would be great if participants could put on an enterprise lens when considering solutions....

Posted by James on December 09, 2005 at 08:33 AM PST #

My response to James - http://blogs.sun.com/superpat/entry/adfs_ws_federation_and_saml

(I know it's nearly three years down the line, but I just linked here and noticed that it wasn't clear I'd responded.)

Posted by Pat Patterson on October 28, 2008 at 03:27 PM PDT #

Post a Comment:

Comments are closed for this entry.
 

    OpenSSO - Get It Now

    Identity Management Buzz Podcast
    Stay connected to news, show notes and leave your feedback.
    Listening To
    Listen to Radio Pat
    www.flickr.com
    superpat7's photos More of superpat7's photos
    Technorati
Valid XHTML or CSS?
[This is a Roller site]
Original theme by Rowell Sotto. Heavily modified by Pat Patterson.