Welcome Vivek's Weblog

Saturday Sep 30, 2006

Why are Eclipse users moving to Netbeans?


Charles Ditzel has an interesting blog entry on this issue. One
of the reasons I find it interesting is because he uses content from
posters on Javalobby to support most of his arguments. I would be very
interested in hearing the comments of the people who wrote the posts
that he uses to support his arguments.


So what are some of his reasons why Eclipse users are going to
Netbeans? One is the speed issue which has been discussed here.
Netbeans has been getting faster since version 3.5, whereas Eclipse
seems to keep getting slower. Another reason is that Eclipse does not
support platforms other than Windows very well, primarily because of
SWT. Ditzel cites one post on Javalobby about how the GTK binding for
SWT is so slow, it is practically unusable.


The URL to the blog entry is here so that you can see if your posts are among the ones he used:


http://cld.blog-city.com/read/1126337.htm

Comments:

Why can't you guys just try to make a Java IDE that is GOOD ON ITS OWN, rather than trying to always compare it to a far more widely accepted IDE. instead of "we're better than eclipse!" why don't you try "we're really good!" Why does everything have to be a damn competition? Just do the best you can do, forget everyone else. I use Eclipse just fine on Linux, Windows and Mac (yes, I use all three.) 512mb of RAM is more than enough for a fast-running Eclipse, no matter what platform you're on, and the arguements that SWT is not platform-independent are rubbish. Since when is a toolkit that runs on 5 different platforms not platform independent? Geez.

Posted by jeremiah johnson on October 01, 2006 at 09:43 AM IST #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed