Perplexed looking for a guide

Rich Zippel's Weblog
Tuesday May 30, 2006

Advertising is Evil

I came back from a long business trip a couple of weeks ago, and what struck me was all the advertising I kept running into. It was on the walls of the airport terminal, on the coffee bug I picked up, on the TV monitors in the waiting area, etc. I thought I might get a break when I got on the airplane, but no, even the in flight shows included commercials!

When I got home, I played with my sons for a bit and then they watched a TV show. I guess I shouldn't be surprised that they were more in tune with the commercials than real content of the the shows they were watching. After they went to sleep I watched a Red Sox game for the first time in quite a while. Not only were there commericals during the breaks in the action, but even during a pitch you could see the advertising on the stands behind the batter. I was pretty fed up. I hadn't realized how good I had it locked up in a conference room for a week drinking coffee, Dr, Pepper, and eating strawberry licorice and cookies.

I don't mind seeing a mind seeing an ad every once in a while. Sometimes they inform or are amusing, like the current Apple ads. But more often then not they are annoying. Afterall, that's why God invented Tivo---to restore a balance with the evils of adverising and commercials.

But then it hit me. My last refuge from commercials and advertising was the library. There are never commericals there, just books and people reading them. But today, the library is being replaced by the Internet (see the May 14, 2006 NYTimes article in the magazine section). And what's the portal to the Internet library? It's Google. And Google is constantly inserting advertisements around the results of my search.

And when you look at business plans for startups these days, it seems the most common approach is that by using this nifty new technology they invented, they will create a unique community that can be used for targeted advertising (which of course, we will make unobtrusive but which the users will find irresistible). Isn't there a way to provide real value to your targeted community? Is advertising the only way to make money these days?

Comments:

Hi Rich, Glad to see you’re posting. My girlfriend and I don't have a TV at home patricianly for the same reason. I had my first job in advertising and I did develop some admiration for the creative effort however the internal culture is hell for the typical MIT graduate. Dont' let the clutter get to you.

Posted by Jorge Barrera on November 01, 2006 at 10:41 AM EST #

Hi Rich, Glad to see you're watching the Sox, maybe this year, eh? Anyway, coming back from the US to the UK, after two years in Cambridge, MA, was eye opening. We'd grown immune to the number and type of advertising on US TV, Radio and sports. We talked about it on our return. The US advertising industry sacrifices quality for quantity - except for SuperBowl! Take time out to look at some UK TV commercials next time you travel.... Oh, and we don't have commercials between the end-of-show and the end-of-show-credits. Advertising in the UK is heavily regulated, both in terms of what can be said, and on TV how much advertising there can be in any 60 minute period. This makes life more predictable. But it doesn't make it less annoying. Some years ago a commercial TV company bought the rights to Grand Prix racing - it had been on public service TV (no commercials) since forever. Every Grand prix since you've missed about 10 laps in total due to commercials - including the finish of one, and spectacular overtaking manouvers in others. Advertising targetted at kids is the current focus of regulatory development. But, the most insidious form of all to me is the trend for 'active' advertising boards around the pitch perimeter of soccer matches. On TV, these large backlit moving images distract hugely from the sport i'm trying to watch - which I guess is the idea :) - of course, my reaction is that certain well known sports and vehicle manufacturers don't get my business....

Posted by Mike Wonham on February 06, 2007 at 04:07 PM EST #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed

Archives
Links
Referrers